E. Thomas McClanahan is a Kansas City Star Editorial Page columnist and he has possibly written the most racist thing I've ever seen in The Star in maybe a decade.
He's the house Conservative at the paper-of-record and his thinking about defining crime by racial standards is not only repugnant but reveals the "professional standards" at The Star are also fading along with their revenue, profit margins and employees.
Take a look:
"What’s missing is the rate at which each ethnic group violates the law. Different groups have different tendencies, and they can vary in unpredictable ways. For example, black males commit a disproportionate number of murders, but most serial murders are committed by white males."
This line is pretty disgusting and it's not even clever enough to make it on a blog. Sadly, I think the dude is serious.
Similarly, this kind of attitude is probably why coverage of diverse communities is so poor at the paper of record.
Really, it's all just a hot mess over there and McClanahan's screed doesn't represent Conservatism or anything remotely akin to logic. It's just another reactionary online post that represents the worst kind of lazy, stereotypical thinking.
In fact, even his smear about white dude serial killers (that I've used before in jest) is actually easily contradicted by the great diversity of serial killers in this town alone.
TKC Advice: Conservative or not, whenever white dudes find themselves wanting to write about the "tendencies of different groups" they should seriously count to ten or go buy a clue.
No sir, I don't like it.
ReplyDeleteThe truth is not racist.
ReplyDeleteBlack people steal TV's
Mexicans mow lawns and install shingles
Indians stink like curry
Asians are good at math
White people rock.
TKC, you apparently didn't understand statistics. You also didn't mention that "Even Koster admitted the report he so eagerly promoted doesn’t support clear conclusions. “A high disparity rate is not proof of racial profiling,” he said during his Kansas City stop.
ReplyDeleteSo, once again, if it doesn't fit TKC's agenda, then he leaves out the facts and reasoning.
It's TKC's blog, and he can say what he wants, but he should try not to sound like an idiot.
tony-parkville, it's McClanahan who is the idiot. He used Koster's report to justify his own rant about the "tendencies" of minorities. If you don't understand that's wrong then you're just as bigoted as that guy.
ReplyDeleteyes, anon 12:51 - now I'm a biggot because I understand the flaw in the numbers. Did you actually read the McClanahan column? Here's another part that TKC didn't mention:
ReplyDelete"So a study was conducted, in which motorists were photographed while being clocked with radar guns. As Heather Mac Donald of the Manhattan Institute reported, researchers found that black motorists on the New Jersey Turnpike made up 25 percent of the speeders in 65 mph zones, even though they were only 16 percent of the driving population.
Black drivers were twice as likely to speed as whites — yet only 23 percent of the traffic stops involved African-American drivers. By that measure, blacks were stopped less than they should have been.
If a disparity study doesn’t provide the “violator benchmark,” it’s close to worthless. Worse, like the study Koster released last week, it can encourage poorly thought-out ideas aimed solely at moving the numbers."
Tony, if you're going to be a racial whiner, you could stand to read up on some sociology.
ReplyDeleteThere are a lot of statistics you would find unsettling. The reason why you don't know these things is that you weren't around to see the great changes between 1950 and 1970.
Gen X'ers just weren't around during the Sixties (like when Johnson County went from wheatfields to suburbia, and middle class pre-war neighborhoods on the streetcar lines turned ghetto.
Gen'Xer textbooks were already santitized. Academics got watered down so everyone could graduate if they just showed up for class.
And also they didn't give their grandparents the time of day so they never heard the stories about life in KC before The Brady Bunch.
Ya missed out. Comparing GenX to the WWII generation is like comparing Sarah Palin to Benjamin Franklin. He went to France and England, and wrote Common Sense. All she could see was Russia from her house and reading the sports on Anchorage TV.
To Tony-Parkville and Radioman:
ReplyDeleteGuys, we all appreciate your efforts out here w/ TKC but surely you don't really expect any responsible information or evaluation on here by this Tony, do you? It's just all CAPITALIZATION and exclamation points!!! and pretending he has a handle on things.
It's really tiresome.
And pathetic. I can't forget pathetic.
Taking rightwing, conservative Thomas McLanahan seriously?
ReplyDeleteAre you kidding?
Who is this, Jack Cashill?
da'mam loves tony
ReplyDeleteHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
ReplyDeleteNow that was funny.
The opinion piece is at http://www.kansascity.com/2010/06/05/1995496/a-racial-profiling-report-that.html
ReplyDeleteTony linked it. Stop spamming.
ReplyDelete